Sunday, October 20, 2013

A blighted birding patch

As is evident to anyone who reads my posts, our recent birding has been carried out within fairly restricted boundaries. In Illinois, it was our now extinct and lamented "back yard" prairie (Remembering birds in a vacant lot). In Florida, a convenient wetlands preserve adjacent to our subdivision is a scarred but welcome haven for resident and migratory species.

Since moving to south Florida in 2004 I have recorded a respectable 126 bird species in this local tract. Most are documented among over 5,500 photos that may be viewed in this FLICKR set: West Miramar Water Conservation Area

As happened with my Illinois "back yard" patch, this area is slated for massive development in the near future. This time it will not succumb to residential subdivisions or shopping centers. The mile-long stretch of gravel road that now provides access (Miramar Parkway/SW 196th Avenue right of way) will be paved and become a four-lane high speed parkway, to connect two major highways, I-75 and US-27. 

Most of the wetlands will be surrounded by 13-15 foot levees and flooded to a depth of up to 4-5 feet to become a huge retention reservoir. We hope that some terrestrial habitat is included in the project, to mimic the hardwood hammocks of the original Everglades. The Harbour Lakes mitigation area with its two lakes will remain outside the new reservoir, but the roadway will run along its eastern and northern edges.

This photo, which I took at sunrise just this past week, is the gravel right-of-way which will become the planned parkway.

Miramar Parkway to NW HDR 20131005

The very spot, where I stood to take this picture of an immature Great Blue Heron and Great Egret with an assemblage of Roseate Spoonbills and White Pelicans in the Harbour Lakes wetland, will be paved and busy with traffic. 

Great Egret with Imm Great Blue and pelicans 20121125

The high levee will run along this row of abandoned telephone poles, dashing hopes that they might serve as sites for Osprey nest platforms. The open wet prairie to the right of the photo is part of the Harbour Lakes mitigation area that will not be included in the impoundment and presumably will continue to be actively maintained as a preserve.

Abandoned Utility Easement 20121205

Part of the US Army Corps of Engineers plan to restore sheet flow to the historic Everglades, the reservoir will serve to prevent diversion and seepage of rain water, which now flows in canals directly out of the Everglades to the ocean. The retained water will recharge the aquifer and keep salt water from intruding into the water table that supplies the residents and industries of the entire populated southeastern Florida peninsula. A system of pumps and waterways will regulate water flow, and biologic action in the standing water will remove agricultural pollutants such as phosphorus and nitrogen.

As this map illustrates, the reservoir, outlined in red and designated by the US Army Corps of Engineers as "Impoundment C-9," will be 3.5 miles from north to south, and up to 1.2 miles wide. LINK: The Broward County Water Preserve Area (BCWPA) is part of the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan (CERP). 

To get an idea of the size of this project, US Highway 27 (Okeechobee Road), to the left, is about 5 miles west of Interstate I-75. At the northern edge, the small rectangular woodland that contains the Bald Eagle nest which we succeeded in having declared a sanctuary, will be spared.

C-9 Impoundment Map 20130929

Much of the land to be inundated had been "permanently" set aside by developers to compensate for the damage done to the Everglades by construction of subdivisions. 

The dedicated preserve consists of agricultural fields that, in the early 1900s, were "reclaimed" from the Everglades by draining and filling. Under the mitigation plan, these lands were subsequently managed to become a water conservation area. Drainage ditches were blocked and low levees were constructed around its perimeter. Exotic vegetation was removed. Although isolated from the main Everglades preserve (which is west of US-27) it collected rain water during the summer and dried out in winter, loosely mimicking the ebb and flow of the historic wild lands.

When we first came to Florida, the land was returning to a more natural state of wet prairie where Sawgrass and Spikerush flourished. With announcement of the C-9 project, all maintenance ceased and now the area designated for the reservoir is rapidly returning to a woodland populated by Australian Pine, Melaleuca, Brazilian Pepper and other invasive shrubs, grasses and vines. 

This is an example of one area that was a wet prairie only about 7 years ago. Now it is choked with shrubs.

Shrub Overgrowth in wetlands preserve  20131013

After it is flooded, upland species such as Bobcat, White-tailed Deer will be evicted. This Bobcat eyed our approach as it sat right in the middle of the gravel road...

Bobcat close HDR 20121005

...and an eight-point buck peered out from the edge of the road.

Whitetail deer buck 20120724

Other upland species will lose their habitat, such as Raccoons...

Raccoon 20120419

...and Florida Box Turtles, both also captured as they ventured out on the roadway.

Box Turtle 20130416

Of course, when the project is completed, it should support a rich habitat for fish-eating species such as herons, Osprey and Bald Eagles.

Tricolored Heron:

Tricolored Heron Preening 20090601


Osprey 29119396Copy

Bald Eagle with fish stolen from Osprey, on the Harbour Lakes mitigation area:

Bald Eagle 0739-26 AM 20121010

In the meantime, recreational off-road vehicle drivers are having their way with the wetlands, as efforts to restore them have been abandoned. Supposedly, under state law, these lands held "in perpetuity"  under deed restrictions and conservation easements will be replaced by "similar" acreage somewhere else in the State of Florida.

Before, during wet season:

Flooded thicket 20100204

Same location after visited by the all-terrain vehicles:

ORV tracks in wetlands 20131013

Another example, on posted water conservation easement (note that the "No Trespassing" sign has been knocked over by the fun-seekers):

West Miramar WCA damage 20120128


  1. i am sorry you are losing the natural wetlands area to freeway development and the reservoir system. they put in a similar water reservoir place and pumping station in a nearby town but it helped give migratory waterfowl a place to rest and refill. and they put in a birding and wildlife viewing area next to it so it actually improved the raw fields that had been there before.

  2. @Tex-- Thanks, Theresa. As I understand it there will be opportunity for public comment on recreational uses for the impoundment, such as fishing, canoeing and wildlife watching. I hope there will be some consideration given to having at least one artificial hammock for upland species of birds and other fauna.

  3. Man's "progress" rarely takes wildlife into consideration.

  4. Gob smacked. I really hope things aren't as bleak as the picture you paint.

    I am sure there are some downtown slums somewhere that could be flattened and would make for a better highway????

  5. You have some amazing wildlife to watch and photograph... many thanks for sharing this post.

  6. I'm not sure this can be called progress. I'd rather see untouched nature and wildlife than highways.

  7. That is a very bleak outlook for the birds and wildlife in what is now beautiful habitat. IMO most developments now do not do much good for the local wildlife.

  8. Hi Ken This looks a terrible situation and certainly in my opinion not progress. Your photographs are this post are marvelous as usual.

  9. The plans for your area are heartbreaking for people like us. This does not constitute progress in our minds, but it is the way of the times. It is so sad. When I look at your beautiful pictures and think that all of this will be disturbed and in places destroyed, I really do feel depressed about it all. I grew up in south Florida and know how beautiful and sacred these areas are. Thanks so much for sharing your pictures and information with us this week. genie

  10. It is so sad to think of the loss of habitat for the beautiful animals pictured in this post.

  11. I love Florida, but when I hear/see things like this going on it breaks my heart, everthing has to be done at the expence of wild life. money, greed, or sport the wild life suffers.
    All the best Gordon.

  12. This comment has been removed by the author.


Thank you for visiting Rosyfinch Ramblings! I will enjoy a visit to your page just as soon as possible. Some anonymous comments and some containing active links may not be accepted.